L'Oreal ParisVoluminous Brown Balm Volumizing Mascara, Washable, Brown, 0.26 Fl Oz., 1 Count

My favorite brown mascara right now! It goes on good and I never have smudges under my eyes. It rarely flakes off too!

The Voluminous Original was recently reformulated. It made my lids so itchy that I ended up pulling a lot of my lashes out by sort of picking at itchy parts over the day; I think it dries too hard. This Voluminous Balm version reminds me of the old Voluminous version. If I pull any off, the mascara comes off my lashes rather than taking the whole lash with it. I'd rather keep my lashes than have my mascara stay put for 18 hours.I also like the brush. My lashes are long and can get messy, the brush does just that, it brushes them nicely and they look tidy and defined.

I haven't worn mascara in years, but my heart daughter's wedding is coming up soon and there will be family wedding pictures taken, so I had to break down and buy mascara. Finding brown mascara is difficult especially non-waterproof.I really like the color, and it does make my eyelashes look longer.I did a "test run" yesterday and overall, it didn't make my eyes itch until late into the day (Allergy issues). It did flake a little, but not bad. It was easy to take off with hot water and a washcloth.This was a good choice for me.

Wears well and doesn’t flake off. Easy to remove. Great brown color.

I don't usually knock products and I was an avid Loreal user in the past for lots of years butto be honest ibdon't care for this mascara. It doesn't lengthen my upper and lower lashes very much and I don't care for the applicator. I was expecting better results..

Over the past 18 months, I have ordered over $100 in different mascaras trying to find a mascara that won't smudges under the eyes even just using it on the upper lashes. I tried everything from Chanel to Cover Girl, regular and waterproof, black and brown. They all smudge but this was the best of them. It smudges but less than the others.

Another new favorite. It not to dark for my skin tone.

Tooo thick to use. I did it overnight for an event and now can't use it once delivered. Just a thick clump on brush.Very disappointing. Should have stuck with my estee lauder brand!